American Idol - Top 10 Girls

Let's start by saying that you WILL NOT hear me go on and on about any of the girl contestants like I did about a certain boy contestant (I won't say his name or I might forget that I'm writing about the girls today & not him)...

I'll start by saying that the girls are MUCH more inconsistent than the guys...they've been pretty predictable (for the most part) as to who will be great & who will not. The girls are all over the board. Here is how we ranked the girls from last night...

1. Carly - this was the first that I actually liked her performance...I thought it was really good, but I'm still not "in love" with her.

2. Brooke - You're So Vain was the perfect song for her - she even looks like Carly Simon, doesn't she?

3. Ramiele - great song, but when I hear that song, I always think of Vonzell doing that in season 4 & there's just no comparison

4. Kristy - way better this week than last week - I liked her song, but I agree that she needs to do the country route - she and Alaina both remind me so much of Carrie Underwood (my favorite Idol winner!)

5. Kady - I thought it was WAY better than the week before, but I think she's one of the ones that stands a chance of going just because she hasn't really wow-ed anyone yet

6. Syesha - not a good song choice, hopefully she makes it through tonight

7. Alaina - not a good song choice, same as Syesha

8.Alexandrea* - Very poor song choice & way too safe, I think

9. Amanda - I thought she sounded & looked terrible last night...I was never sold on the rocker-chick image though...I agree w/ Paula that she looks so much better "natural" like we saw her when she was doing her little segment before the song.

10. Asia'h* - I agree w/ Simon - she's just not a very good singer...

It's a toss-up between the last three girls listed, but if I had to choose, I would say Alexandrea and Asia'h, just since I think Amanda might have a little more of a following of voters since she's got a "style" which the other two don't have...can't wait to find out!